Whenever I walk by any pastry store and see brownies, I stop there for a while, wondering how that brownie would taste. If it looks unique and appealing, I buy and bring it to the house to have a closer look and get more of how it's baked.
As a brownie-holic, having the best brownie pan is really important, as the pan is one of the factors that influence the quality and taste of this dessert. If you have been on several online marketplaces to find a good quality pan for this purpose, I have a few recommendations for you in this regard.
Wilton Aluminum Square Cake and Brownie Pan
5 out of 5
Baker’s Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan
5 out of 5
Silivo Silicone Brownie Pan with Dividers
4.5 out of 5
Gotham Steel Brooklyn Brownie Non-Stick Copper Baking Pan
4 out of 5
Goodcook Biscuit/Brownie Pan Nonstick Bakeware
4.5 out of 5
Best Pan for Brownies in 2021
Below, I have listed pans for brownies of different shapes and sizes. You will find the right one as per your preference and baking requirements from these suggestions.
1. Wilton Aluminum Square Cake and Brownie Pan
In any brownie pan, the first thing that you need to consider after the size factor is the material used for the pan. As a perfectly baked brownie always demands even heat distribution, having an aluminum gauge made pan like this one would be a worthwhile consideration.
This 8.9 inches square-shaped pan has a depth of 2 inches that assures you of high rise brownies as well as cakes. There are other sizes available from 6 to 16 inches of square, rectangle, and round shapes.
As I mentioned earlier, this one got an aluminum construction; it assures you of even heating for uniform baking. The material is rust-resistant for commercial-level performance. So, yeah, if you are a professional baker, this pan will suit you as well. Just make sure you get the larger pan for commercial purposes.
If you are to try brownies or cakes for the first time using the pan, family members, as well as guests, won't even imagine that you are a beginner.
The surface comes really smooth and makes decoration a lot easier. Its sturdy sides and rolled lips help to bake beautifully straight edges whether you try making brownies or cakes.
Cleaning the pan is as easy as a pie. You can easily clean it in warm soapy water for the best cleaning results.
2. Baker’s Edge Nonstick Edge Brownie Pan
The title will appeal much to the edge lovers. These individuals mostly like brownies because of the edges. Not all the pans are good for perfectly baked chewy edges. You will need a pan like this one to be able to achieve the desired thing.
Unlike conventional larger ones, the pan is designed in a way that you will be able to bite two edges every time, which makes it the best pan for brownies. Cakes and brownies will come long in shape with two edges.
Despite its unusual chamber design, you can easily spread the batter on the entire pan without struggling. Construction-wise, the pan got durable gauge cast aluminum material along with the nonstick coating. So, you can rest assured about the durability. It will easily survive drops and lite abuses.
Due to its aluminum construction, the heat distribution is much better than conventional pans. Thus, you get evenly baked cakes and brownies from all sides. No portion will remain uncooked or undercooked, that’s for sure.
This 9x12 inches all edge brownie pan perfectly fits all box mixes as well as conventional recipes.
The pan is easy to clean from both inside and outside. So, unlike cheaper ones, its easy cleanup makes sure there is no grease and grime left on the surface after cleaning, thus assuring you of hygiene issues.
3. Silivo Silicone Brownie Pan with Dividers
Unlike a regular full-size brownie baking pan, this silicone made pan makes smaller brownie pieces of 2 inches in diameter. At a time, you can bake 12 pieces of brownies, keto fat bombs, cupcakes, muffins, chocolates, and other desserts as per your choice.
The pan measures 11.2x7.3 inches in dimension. You will get brownies of 1-inch depth. There are pans of 9 and 12 inches with more rooms for cakes and brownies. However, the color remains the same regardless of the size.
Although the pan is silicone made, the material is 100% food grade and BPA-free. Thus, it’s safe to use and more eco-friendly than conventional pans. The pan doesn’t have any chemical coating whatsoever. You can use it without worrying about health issues.
The pan is good to go inside an oven and withstands up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit without causing any damage to its BPA-free silicone material.
If you previously used other pans, you are probably well-familiar with odor and stain issues. Thankfully, you will not experience anything like that using this silicone brownie pan.
Being a silicone pan, it's flexible and allows you to quickly release the baked items. If anything causes to lose its regular shape, you can easily fix it effortlessly.
When it comes to cleaning the pan, you can use the dishwasher and warm soapy water to thoroughly clean without much hassle.
4. Gotham Non-Stick Square Pan for Brownie
If you regularly bake cakes, muffins, cupcakes, and brownies, you probably would like to get two different pans, one for full size and another for small pieces of desserts.
However, you can opt for this multi-purpose baking pan that serves you in both ways. You can bake smaller pieces or an entire cake without spending in another pan.
Made of aluminum material, your desserts will be baked evenly all the time. The inner divider is made of safe copper metal to ensure its durability. You can conveniently use an electric mixer inside the pan. The surface will not get scratched whatsoever.
Its nonstick and sturdy surface make sure the brownies or cakes come out nicely without breaking the pieces. There is no need to use butter or oil for popping up the baked goodies smoothly.
This brownie baking dish can make you 18 perfectly sliced desserts whether you use it for making cakes, muffins, brownies, chocolates, etc. What’s more interesting is, you can also make pizza squares using the same pan.
The pan is PFOA free, so you are assured about the health concerns of your family and kids. Inside the oven, this brownie tray can withstand up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit easily.
Due to its aluminum material, the pan is much safer for dishwashers. You can easily get rid of stains and odors using a standard dishwasher without doing much cleaning hassle.
5. Goodcook Biscuit/Brownie Pan
All the baking pans for brownies that I have reviewed so far can also be used for baking cookies and side dishes, along with cakes and brownies. This is no exception to this pan. It got some reliable housing and a nonstick smooth baking surface that will surely enhance your baking experience.
The pan measures 11x7 inches, which is a standard size for baking cakes. You can use a standard mixer to deal with batter in the pan.
Its surface handles heat wisely, making sure that the heat is evenly distributed to the dessert. Thanks to the heavy-duty gauge steel that stands out impressively against warping, you get perfectly baked items regardless of your baking skills.
For the well-being of your kids and other family members, the nonstick cooking surface is PFOA-free. This also eases the cleaning and stuff. You can use a regular dishwasher to thoroughly clean the inside of the pan and eliminate stains, grease, and odors.
This deal only gets you a single brownie baking pan. You can opt for two to four-pack of pans that might be a cost-efficient deal for you if you regularly have to bake numbers of cakes as well as other dessert items.
6. Wilton Perfect Results Non-Stick Mini Loaf Pan
This deal comes with a mini loaf pan and nonstick baking pan for brownies, cakes, and similar desserts. If you purchase these two items separately from the marketplace, it will cost you more than what this combo pack comes at.
As you are primarily looking for a brownie pan, let's talk about this one first. With reliable steel construction along with a nonstick baking surface, you can expect it to last years while delivering you perfectly cooked dessert items consistently. The material doesn't warp, unlike what we find in cheaply made pans.
Whether you bake brownies, cakes, cookies, and other items, its nonstick surface will evenly distribute heat all over the batter. You don't need to slice the dessert into pieces, as it comes with 12 serving cavities for convenience. The size is perfect for small cupcakes and muffins as well.
Talking about its versatile loaf pan, you can bake bread, cakes, and other soft baking items without compromising much taste and flavor. This one is also made of durable steel material, and the inner surface got a nonstick coating that eases the release.
Cleaning both the pans is fairly easier. You can use a dishwasher and get rid of stains as well as odors without putting much effort.
For ease of handling, these pans have oversized handles; you can easily put it in and bring it out of the oven wearing oven mitts.
7. Caketime Pan For Baking Brownies
If you want cool looking pans for baking muffins, brownies, cupcakes of different sizes and shapes, this can be the best pan for baking brownies for such needs.
Similar to the previous deal, this one comes with multiple pans for different baking needs. You will get one round 12-cup baking mold, one 24-cup mini baking mold, and one rectangular 12-cup brownie mold. You don't have to see the same boring looking dessert of the same size and shape.
So, this 3-in-1 value pack can help you to prepare 48 tasteful and flavor enriched baking treats. You don't need any other baking pan for making small-sized desserts.
The molds are made of 100% safe food-grade silicone that can survive up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit temperature. These are tasteless, safe for electric and microwave ovens, dishwashers, freezers, and pretty much everything that has to deal with food.
Compared to other pans, popping out the treats is much easier. These nonstick surfaces are flexible, and you simply press fingers to release the goodies. Cleaning is pretty much hassle-free as all are dishwasher safe.
If you are overly concerned with your health, I can assure you about the safety of these pans. The materials are BPA-free and LFGB approved for being safe to put inside ovens.
8. Chicago Metallic Professional Brownie Tray
Most people prefer making small-sized brownies. It's even better if they don't have to slice the entire brownie. Say hello to another pan on the list with an inner divider. At a time, this tray of brownies can make you 15 pieces of treats.
No need for slicing the treat. Whether you make cupcakes, muffins, or brownies, you can also decorate them while not popping the pieces of the tray. For more convenience, the tray is removable. So, if you feel like baking a full-size cake or brownie, you can slice as per your preference; you are good to go with it.
The pan is made of heavy-duty aluminized steel that also assures you of evenly heat distribution. Your desserts get equal heat from all the sides and come out with a flavorful taste.
Unlike cheaper ones, the nonstick coating on its surface is of high quality. As a result, you can pretty much effortlessly release the desserts without making any cracks on the pieces.
Apart from easy baking, its silicone-based surface is much easier to clean. Consider handwashing the pan for its longevity. You will be able to clean it properly while leaving no trace of stains and odors. Make sure you dry it properly before storing it.
The material is safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit. So, nothing to worry about its safety in the oven.
9. Sweese Porcelain | Best 8x8 Brownie Pan
If you are looking for an all-purpose brownie baking dish that can also be used for baking cakes, roasted meat, baked pasta, casseroles, lasagna, desserts, and many more snacks, take a look at this porcelain made dish. It’s one of the safest oven-friendly materials, so there are no health issues associated with it whatsoever.
Porcelain is a durable, LEAD-free, chip-resistant material, which is sturdier than most stoneware that is available in the market. Also, you can directly place the dish in an oven from a freezer without any issues.
The material is scratch-resistant, and it's very difficult to break. So, you can pretty much use it as a regular dish without causing any damage to it. No other type of bakeware will allow you to use it for different purposes similar to this one.
No need to take the dish out of the pan. This pan got an elegant appearance that goes perfectly when it comes to serving your guests.
There are multiple colors to choose from. You will find the right color that matches other dishes on the table. If you have other Sweese dishes, it will match perfectly with the set.
Apart from baking performance and appearance, the material is also easier to wash using dishwashers. You can hand wash the dish as well. The porcelain texture will make cleaning an easier task.
10. Bakelicious Crispy Corner Brownie Pan
Last but not least, this brownie pan from Bakelicious is made of durable stainless steel material, which is primarily designed for baking brownies.
For those who love the edges of brownies, this one is worth spending the money on. You will feel pleasant crispy edges in every bite. If you have siblings, this will put an end to the war over the edges.
A baked brownie on this pan has 48 edges, which is much more than what you get using a regular brownie pan. Convenient ones only have 14 edges. It has 3x more edges, which you will surely admire much.
For even baking, the pan got patented posts that result in crispy and perfectly baked brownie edges every time you try the recipe. If you previously struggled with half-baked treats, no more underbaked brownies from now on.
To make releasing the treat easier, the pan got a high-quality nonstick coating. The entire brownie will come out smoothly without cracking. As the nonstick coating is PFOA and PFTE-free, you can rest assured about the health issues.
Your kids will like more of your brownies due to more crispy edges with chocolatey goodness inside every treat.
To keep the pan well functioning, it's recommended to hand wash it every time after baking a brownie.
Top 10 Best Brownie Pan Comparison Chart
Size/baked Pieces Size
Wilton Aluminum Pan
8.9 inches with 2 inches depth
450 degrees Fahrenheit
Baker’s Nonstick Pan
Cast aluminium with non-stick coating
Single continuous chamber
Silivo Silicone Brownie Pan
Flexible silicone pan
Up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Easy release and flexible shape
Dishwasher and soapy water
Gotham Brownie Pans
Aluminium and non-stick coating
Square pan with Dividers
Up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit
Goodcook Biscuit Pan
High gauge steel
Traditional square pan
Around 400 degrees Fahrenheit
Wilton Brownie Tray
Quality steel made non-stick coating
Small cavities pan
450 degrees Fahrenheit
Two in one baking pan and mini loaf pan
Caketime Muffin Pan
12 pieces of baking mold, 24 pieces of, 12 pieces of brownie mold
Flexible silicone pan
Up to 446 degrees Fahrenheit
3 in 1 multipurpose baking pan
Chicago Pan for Brownies
15 pieces of treats
Food grade aluminium steel
Inner cavities pan
Up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Allows custom decoration on treats
Sweese Porcelain Square Pan
Traditional glass baking pan
500 degrees Fahrenheit
Scratch and chip-resistant
Bakelicious Corner Brownie Pan
Up to 350 degrees Fahrenheit
Bakes brownies with more edges
Brownie Pans Buying Guide
No matter what pan you get, it will manage to bake brownies for you. However, if you have special preferences and want some extra features to enhance the baking experience without compromising much taste and flavor, be sure to check for the following things while buying your desired pan.
As this is something that will get exposed to high heat inside ovens, you need to make sure the material is durable and safe for foods. Most durable models are made of stainless steel materials. However, there are some models with steel material as well, which are also reliable.
Typically, the inner surface of the pan has a nonstick coat. Make sure the one you get has a higher quality coating. The quality of the coating will determine how easily the brownies and cakes will be released from the pan without causing any damage to the dessert.
If the pan got a quality nonstick coating, it would be a lot easier for you to clean the surface after baking the goodies.
There are some great alternatives to traditional aluminum and nonstick pans. These bakeware are made of food-grade silicone that is remarkably flexible. Small brownie pieces come out easily when you push or pop them. You can fix the structure of silicone materials as well.
Nonstick and aluminum materials are easy to clean. You can use a conventional dishwasher to clean stains and odors that build after you remove the brownie from the pan.
Flexible silicone pans aren’t dishwasher safe. You need to hand wash them to make sure the pan lasts longer.
Safety - Food Grade
The best pan for brownies would be of food-grade material, BPA-free, and safe for the oven, be it in a microwave or electric. Don't compromise this factor whatsoever. Check whether your desired pan checks these characteristics.
Removable Grids and Dividers
Some plain pans come with grids and dividers that you can also remove and place according to the baking requirements. This allows you to pour the batter directly onto the pan, and you might be able to use a mixer if the model has a scratch-resistant surface.
Then, simply place the divider or grid set, and your brownies will come out of the oven well sliced—no need to slice it further.
Types of Brownie Pans
You probably have come across pans of different sizes and shapes while searching for baking brownies. These pans are mostly of two types regardless of their shapes and sizes.
A. Traditional Pans
These are the most commonly used ones that are available in rectangular and square shapes. There are no inner dividers and special features except for the handles on some models.
If you want to bake plain brownies, then this type of pan will make pouring batter a lot easier in it. You also don't need excess preparation.
B. Molded Pans
On the contrary, these feature inner dividers or cavities that don't require slicing the treat. However, when it comes to pouring the batter into the pan or dividers, you need to make sure you do it while maintaining precision and accuracy. Otherwise, the batter will spill on the tabletop.
This type is for those who have to prepare a lot of brownies and don't have much time to slice those into pieces.
Apart from regular rectangular and square shapes, there are models with attractive and cool looking patented shapes. However, depending on the model, these dividers can be removed as per baking preference.
No matter how many sizes and shapes of brownie or baking pans you come across, all of them will come under these two categories.
Top 5 Brownie Pan Brands on the Market
If you are to get your first brownie pan, get familiar with some of the well-reputable brands. It would help you to make the right decision.
Being one of the oldest players in the market, Wilton gained a good reputation among its customers for quality kitchen products. They make quality bakeware made of high-grade aluminum with good nonstick coating.
2. Baker’s Edge
As the name goes, you will get the highest quality and finest material from this manufacturer. Two friends started this company. And they are making a wide variety of baking items, tools and accessories.
3. Chicago Metallic
This is one of the few companies that make no compromise when it comes to their baking pans. Their pans have one of the highest quality nonstick coatings that ease the release like no others.
4. Gotham Steel
The company only deals with cookware, which also includes bakeware, of course. For brownies, you must make sure the pan is made of high-grade aluminum for even heat distribution. Gotham Steel assures you about it. You cannot complain about overcooked or undercooked brownies using their pans.
If you want an alternative to regular metallic bakeware, Sweese is a company that you can rely upon. Their bakeware is made of quality glass material that can withstand high oven temperatures without any issue.
You can bake brownies in their glass baking dish and use the same bakeware for baking other snacks and meals as well.
Glass Vs Metal Brownie Pan: Which One to Choose?
I have listed both glass and metal brownie pans in the review section. If this makes you confused, let me elaborate on the differences a little bit.
1. Glass Baking Pans
These are versatile. Meaning you can use the same bakeware for baking your favorite brownies, pasta, lasagna, casseroles, roasted meats, and similar dishes.
Compared to metal ones, glass pans hold temperature longer. Thus, make sure you always decrease the recommended temperature for glass by 25 degrees than what the recipe suggests for baking in metal bakeware. Your baked item will remain hot for a long time; you can directly serve it on the table.
2. Metal Pans
Conversely, these heat up faster than glass bakeware. However, these cannot hold the temperature for as long as the glass ones. You cannot use a metal bakeware as a multipurpose one.
But when it comes to baking brownies, nothing comes even close to the level of perfection that metal pans deliver. Your brownies come with crispier edges and eye-soothing brown color.
I would say that if this is solely for baking brownies, cakes, muffins, cupcakes, and similar dessert items, stick to a metal pan for the sake of great taste and flavor. If you want multi-purpose bakeware that can also bake brownies, a glass pan would be a good choice in this regard.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
What kind of pan is best for baking brownies?
Aluminum bakeware with a nonstick coating inside is best for baking brownies. You will get crispier and more flavorful brownies using one of these pans.
Ceramic and glass pans can also bake the dessert. However, the taste won’t be the same.
Do you butter pan for brownies?
It’s always better to grease the baking pan with softened butter or cooking spray. Even if your recipe doesn’t recommend so, be sure to apply a tiny little amount. It will make lifting the dessert a lot easier.
What size is a brownie pan?
Standard brownie pans measure 8x8 inches with 2-3 inches depth. Most pans are rectangular or square-shaped. There are also pans of larger sizes and other fun and attractive looking shapes.
Do brownies take longer in a glass pan?
If you set the same temperature recommended for baking in an aluminum pan, it would bake the dessert faster and overbake it. However, the taste won't be as good as the regular ones. Therefore, if you are to bake in a glass pan, be sure to lower the temperature by 25 degrees to prevent the brownies from overcooking.
Can I use a 9x13 pan instead of an 8x8?
The 9x13 pan size is almost twice the size of an 8x8 pan. If you got a larger pan, make sure you double the number of ingredients. It will spread out the ingredients perfectly while maintaining the taste.
To sum up, consider your baking requirements to get the best brownie pan. For crispier edges, get a patented designed or corner-shaped pan.
If you have to prepare in high quantities, a pan with a removable grid or divider set would be the most efficient one.
Make sure the nonstick coating is of the highest quality; otherwise, you will have to look for a replacement soon.
More Accessories You May Like: