Let us face it; baking is a fun process. And as a baker, you can not simply stop yourself from experimenting with different ingredients to see how things turn out. Well, baking can be all fun and games. But when it is the time to store the baked goods, things can become a little tricky.
You see, cookies are meant to be eaten fresh. But you simply can not finish a whole batch of cookies at one go. That is where the best containers for freezing cookies steps in. They lower the chances of the baked goods getting dried out and becoming a crunchy mess. And in this article, we will make it easier for you to choose one!
5 out of 5
LocknLock Food Storage Container
5 out of 5
OXO Good Cookie Jar
4.5 out of 5
Snapware Food Storage for Desserts
4 out of 5
Sistema Lunch Box
4.5 out of 5
Is It a Good Idea Storing Cookies Inside The Fridge?
Storing the cookies in an airtight container makes proper sense. But what about keeping them in your fridge? The thing is, the temperature plays a crucial role when it comes to storing cookies. And if you keep them in a large cookie jar and at room temperature, they will be great for up to three weeks.
But, you can extend the shelf life by keeping them inside the refrigerator. The shelf life will increase to two months if you do so. However, there is a catch! If the cool air comes in contact with the cookies, they will lose all of their moisture. And that can eventually make them taste bland. The cool air will even rob the chewy trait!
That said, things take a different turn when you bring an airtight cookie jar into the equation. With that container, the cool air will not be capable of dehumidifying the cookies. As a result, they will remain fresh and retain the yummy texture for an extended time.
Our Suggested Top 10 Best Containers for Freezing Cookies Reviews in 2022
All of the cookie jars and containers in the market will claim better than the others. But in reality, many will fail to check the most crucial part of storing cookies: keeping the inside airtight. So, we had to do some testing and comparison with the available models. After the evaluation, these are the ones that stood out to us:
1. Rubbermaid Food Storage Container
One of the first things we considered when choosing the finest containers for freezing cookies is the airtight nature of the container. And Rubbermaid excelled in that factor with flying colors!
Unlike some other containers, this one comes with a proper lid. That will have secure latches to keep the inside airtight. And as it will not let the inside air leak out, you will not need to worry about the cookies getting stiff over time. Also, it is 9.6 cups in size, so you can accommodate a good number of cookies.
Other than that, Rubbermaid has opted for high-quality material for this plastic cookie container. The material is BPA-free and safe for dishwashers, freezers, and microwaves. So, you will not have to worry about your baked goods getting ruined because of toxins.
Moreover, this plastic cookie jar has built-in vents in the lid. That will enable you to warm up the cookies correctly in the microwave. Also, as both the lid and the body of the counter is clear, you will not have any trouble seeing how many cookies are actually in the box. The latches of the lid are also easy to work with.
- The lid comes with secure latches and can create an airtight interior
- 9.6 cups in size, so you can keep a good amount of cookies
- BPA-free and safe for ovens, dishwashers, and freezers
- Has built-in vents on the lid for microwaving the frozen cookies
- As it is clear in color, you can easily see the inside
2. LocknLock Pantry Storage Containers with Flip Top
Want to get your hands on an airtight cookie storage container that is BPA-free and long-lasting at the same time? You need to check out what LocknLock is offering here!
The first thing that makes it get into this list of the best cookie storage containers is its build. It is of high-quality material and has higher durability. As a result, you can expect the plastic container to last for an extended time without showing any signs of cracks or breakages.
But that is not all! The material is BPA-free and non-toxic. Those are something you will not find in regular cookie containers with lids. And this trait makes the storage container safe for the baked products and the environment. It even has a large capacity, which is 10.6 cups. So, you can put a large number of cookies in it.
Additionally, the unit has a stackable design. In other words, you can effortlessly put other containers on top of this stackable cookie storage box. That will enable you to be efficient with the storage space inside your fridge. Also, the lid has quick snapping latches. Those will ensure a proper seal inside and keep the interior airtight.
- Made of high-quality materials, so it has a great build quality
- Free of BPA and toxins
- Durable and long-lasting
- Has a stackable design, meaing you can save space in your fridge
- The lid comes with quick-snapping latches
3. OXO Good Grips Airtight Cookie Jar
You might have heard about OXO Good Grips before. Yes, they are pretty well-known when it comes to offering great cooking accessories and storage solutions. And the trend seems to be the same for this cookie jar.
First of all, the overall size of this jar is 3 quarts. In other words, it has 2.8 liters of capacity. That is a lot, especially when comparing it with most of the remaining jars. So, you can easily make it hold an entire batch of cookies. And as the container has a proper shape, keeping it inside the fridge will not be an issue either.
The jar also comes with an airtight lid. It does a proper job of sealing the inside and making it leakproof. Due to how good of a seal the lid makes, there will be no need to worry about the cookies becoming stiff over time. Also, the seal will enhance the storage life of the baked goods.
Moving the jar around will not be an issue either. The lid has a pop-up button handle. And you can even use that pop-up handle as a gripping point to get the lid off the container. The lid also comes apart quite easily, which will make it easier for you to clean the container. Overall, this is one of the leading cookie jars to keep cookies fresh!
- 3 quarts in size, which means you can keep a good amount of cookies inside
- Has a proper shape and is easy to keep inside the fridge
- Keeps the inside airtight, so the cookies will be fresh
- The lid has a built-in handle, mening you can easily carry it around
- Easy to clean
4. Snapware Portable Storage Carrier for Desserts
Do you usually bake different batches of cookies at one go? Struggle to store them separately? Well, you will not have to go through the hassle of using two different containers anymore if you get this cookie jar from Tupperware.
Unlike most cookie containers, this plastic cookie storage container has two separate layers. You can keep one of the batches on the bottom and the other on the top. And as each of the layers has slots on the bottom, it will be pretty easy to keep the cookies organized inside. The layers also snap right and get out quite effortlessly.
Another thing that makes the box a good pick for the best airtight containers for cookies is the stackable nature. It will be possible to convert this two-layer box into three, four, or even more layered containers. The snapping mechanism of both the segments can be customized and stacked.
Other than that, the overall construction is of high-quality polypropylene. However, the material does not have any toxins or BPA in it. As a result, you will not need to worry about your cookies getting contaminated. The lid also does a proper job of keeping the inside airtight. And the container is dishwasher-safe.
- Has two separate layers, helping you keep different types of cookies fresh
- Each layer has slots on the bottom, making it easier to keep cookies
- Made of BPA and toxin-free polypropylene
- Stackable, and the lid keeps the inside airtight
- Easy to clean
5. Sistema Storage Container for Cookie, Chips
Wouldn’t it be great if you could get your hands on a storage box that will enable you to store large batch cookies? Well, we have found a cookie box that matches that criterion exceptionally well! And yes, it is from Sistema!
As we have stated above, the container has a total capacity of 7 liters. With that amount of space, you can easily keep a large batch of cookies inside your fridge. And the best part is that the cookies will be fresh for an extended time as the lid can create a proper seal inside.
On that note, the lid has easy-locking clips. Thanks to those, you will not have to go through any issues getting the cover on and off. The container even has a modular, stackable design. You can easily keep other storage boxes on the top and efficiently use all of the storage space that your fridge has to offer.
There will be no need to go through any hassles when it comes to cleaning the unit. The box is dishwasher-safe! Also, the overall construction is 100 percent virgin plastic. That means it does not have any phthalate, BPA, or other toxins in it. And you can even heat up the cookies with the container as the unit is microwave-safe.
- The total capacity is 7 liters, so it will be possible to keep loads of cookies
- Comes with a proper lid that can keep the inside airtight
- The lid has easy-locking clips
- Features a modular, stackable design
- Dishwasher-safe and microwave-safe
6. Komax Biokips Airtight Cookie Container
On the hunt for a Tupperware cookie container with a space-saving design? You can stop your search right here because Komax offers something that will perfectly meet your needs.
Yes, the main highlight is the space-saving design! It adopts a square shape and has a compact overall height. That will enable you to accommodate the box inside your fridge easily. But do not think that you will not get enough storage space inside. The overall size is 21 cups, which is more than enough for a large cookie batch.
Aside from having ample space inside, the lid of the box will do a proper job of keeping the inside airtight. It comes with a four-point locking mechanism to ensure no air from the outside gets in. Also, the lid is pretty easy to work with. So, there will be no need to go through extra steps to get the cookies in and out.
The overall construction is of high-quality material. Instead of opting for regular plastic, the brand has utilized BPA-free polypropylene for the box. That makes the unit safe for storing food and safe for the environment. The box even has a stackable design, which will enable you to easily keep other containers on top of this unit.
- Sports a space-saving design
- The overall capacity is 21 cups, so you can store a large number of cookies
- Comes with an efficient lid that keeps the interior airtight
- Made of BPA-free polypropylene, meaning it will be safe for cookies
- Stackable and easy to work with
7. Tupperware Cake Keeper
Bake large-sized cookies? Want something that will let you keep those large-sized cookies without breaking them? This offering from Tupperware is for you!
The thing that makes this cookie container stand out is the shape. No, it doesn’t come in a rectangular or square form factor. Instead, Tupperware has opted for a circular design. Thanks to that, you can keep the large-sized cookies in it without the need to break them into two pieces.
But the shape is not the only thing that this container has going for. It comes with a special lid. That can seal the inside airtight and restrict the outside air from getting inside. Also, there are proper tabs on the cover, which will make it easier for you to get the top off the container.
Moreover, the overall construction of the unit is pretty solid. Both of them are from quality materials and will be capable of withstanding a good amount of load. In other words, you can expect the cookie storage solution to last for a good amount of time without showing any issues.
- It’s a circular shape storage container, so you can keep large-sized cookies
- 12 inches in size and will allow you to keep a good number of cookies inside
- Comes with an airtight lid, so the cookies will remain fresh
- The lid is easy to work with
- Durable and long-lasting
8. Prepara Latchlok Tritan Food Container
While there are many cookie storage boxes out there with a reasonable amount of capacity, only a few can resist stain. And the Latchlok from Prepara is one of those few.
The overall construction of the unit is from Tritan material that is from Eastman. This material is basically a BPA-free version copolyester. And it is highly resistant to staining. Also, the copolyester is clear in color as well. For that reason, you can easily see how many cookies are there on the inside.
Along with being transparent, the material is pretty durable too. It can handle a good amount of kitchen abuse and will not break or crack that easily. Also, as the overall capacity of the box is 13 cups, you can easily keep a large batch of cookies inside it. And for the interlocking lid, you will not need to worry about cold air getting inside.
Alongside that, the container has a space-saving design. You can easily fit this inside the fridge without the need to sacrifice too much space. Also, the unit is stackable. In other words, it will be possible for you to keep other boxes on top of these. Thanks to the non-toxic nature of the material, you can safely put it inside the microwave.
- Made of sturdy material, so it will last longer
- The walls are clear and reasonably tough
- BPA-free and microwave-safe
- Comes with an interlocking lid, so you can easily close the cover
- Space-saving and stackable
9. PROMOZE Microwavable Food Containers For Meal Prepping
Are you tired of carrying regular cookie boxes to your work? Want to amp up your cookie sharing method? This 50-piece package from Promoze is just what you need!
Just like the label states, you will get 50 different containers with the purchase. And the thing that makes it different from most of the other bulk container packages is that you will get reusable boxes with the purchase. So, you can just clean the boxes and use them again and again if you want to.
On top of that, you can use each for an extended time. The containers are reasonably durable and will last for a prolonged period without showing any signs of wear. And as the overall construction is made of food-grade PP material, you can wash it inside the dishwasher without any worries. The boxes are also microwave and freezer-safe.
Alongside that, each container comes with a secure lid. That can properly seal the inside and prevent the outside air from coming inside. Consequently, your cookies will remain fresh inside these boxes for a prolonged time. Also, the boxes have a space-saving design, which will let you easily carry them or store them inside the fridge.
- Comes in a pack of 50, meaning you can work with tons of cookies
- Made of highly durable material
- The material is BPA-free and food-grade
- Each of the boxes comes with a secure lid
- Sports a space-saving design
10. MontoPack Aluminum Foil Containers
Last but not least, we have disposable cookie containers package from Montopack. So, does the disposable trait all that this package has to offer? Not at all!
First of all, with the purchase, you will get your hands on 50 different foil containers. Each of those has a one-handed edge, which helps keep the food inside fresh for a prolonged amount of time. And with each box, you will also get an individual lid. It will be easier for you to get the lid on the top of the boxes for the edge design.
Nonetheless, the boxes are of aluminum foil that is eco-friendly and free from toxin materials. For that reason, you will not have to worry about the cookies getting contaminated with any chemicals. Also, the containers are reusable and washable. So, you can use them multiple times.
The overall size of the containers is pretty respectable. Each can hold up to 2 pounds of food, meaning you can keep a good number of cookies inside. And for the space-saving design of the containers, you can easily accommodate a good number of these into your fridge.
- The purchase will give you 50 different foil boxes
- Each container comes with their own lid
- The containers have an easy one-handed edge
- Can lock the freshness of the cookies inside
- Capable of accommodating a large number of cookies
Containers for Freezing Cookies Comparison Table
Plastic and silicone
14.1 x 10.5 Inches
Silicone and plastic
Aluminum and plastic
Things to Consider Before Buying Containers for Freezing Cookies
Our review section has made it quite easier to choose the best containers for freezing cookies, right? Well, what if we told you that the choosing process could get much more manageable? It surely can! But for that to happen, you will need to keep these crucial points in your mind:
First and foremost, consider the construction material. It will indicate the overall build quality of the container. And the ones that are of low-grade or average-grade plastic will have a lower quality. They will easily break off or show signs of wear after a couple of use.
For that reason, we highly recommend choosing the ones that are of high-quality material. On that note, loads of the brands will not bother utilizing BPA-free and toxin-free materials. Those can get your food contaminated and eventually cause health issues. So, check the safety of the material before making the purchase.
The second thing that should be in your mind is the overall capacity of the container. We recommend you consider how many cookies you usually bake before selecting the size. If you usually make a large batch of cookies at one go, get those with a high storage capacity. Jars will also make sense if you bake mini cookies.
On the other hand, if you happen to cook a small batch of cookies or do not really have much to store, get the ones with 5 to 8 cups of storage. Also, if you like to bake large cookies, opt for round containers. You will not need to break off the cookies to store them in the fridge with those.
Another crucial factor that should be in your consideration is whether the lid can make an airtight seal or not. If you happen to get one that fails to make the inside airtight, you can not use it to store cookies in the fridge. The cool air will get inside and suck out all of the moisture and chewiness from the cookies.
Alongside that, do check whether the lids are easy to work with or not. You would not want to fight with the container and top to create an airtight seal inside. Our recommendation would be to opt for the containers that come with easy snappable latches.
Though most cookie containers are easy to clean, dishwasher-safe ones can take away all of the hassles of cleaning the containers. You just need to put the container on the top rack of the dishwasher and turn the device on. If the container is dishwasher-safe, it will not crack or wear out during the cleaning process.
If you make chocolate chip cookies, you would want to get the chips to melt a little while having the cookie, right? Well, if you get the microwave-safe containers, there will be no need to use a different container to get the cookies reheated in the microwave. So, consider if the box is microwave-safe or not before purchasing.
Tips for Storing and Freezing Cookies
Did you know that you can elongate the lifespan of the cookies if you properly store the cookies inside the container? Yes, you can! And these tips can help you achieve that:
Have a Proper Idea Regarding How Long Cookies Usually Last
First of all, you need to consider that usually, cookies will last for up to two months inside the fridge. But if you keep them inside the freezer, they can last for up to six months. However, you need to consider the ingredients. Some ingredients can go bad quicker than others.
Cool the Cookies Thoroughly
Baking the cookies takes a lot of patience and work. So, we can understand that you would want to rush the storing process to get done with the task. However, you should not rush the cooling process. Before you keep them inside the box, you should ensure that the cookies are cool to the touch.
You will notice condensation forming inside the box even if the cookies are slightly warm. And this will completely ruin your cookies. So, let the cookies rest for a while before storing them inside the freezer.
Keep Different Types of Cookies Separately
It is quite natural for a baker to cook different types of cookies in one baking process. But you should use individual containers for keeping different varieties of cookies. If you keep all of the different kinds in the same place, the crisp ones will get soft, while the soft ones will get hard. That is something you would not want.
Store the Cookies in Layers
Cookies sticking to one another is the last thing that you would want. Well, with just one simple trick, you can prevent that from happening. After arranging the first layer of cookies, you should put waxed paper or parchment paper on top. Then, put the second layer of cookies.
Keep Cookie Bars Correctly
If you are working with cookie bars, you should first slice the bars into small sizes. Then put each of the pieces in the airtight container. If you have perishable ingredients, such as glaze, cream cheese, or others, make sure to handle them carefully when putting them in the box.
Store Cookies without Frosting
You should store the cookies without putting any frosting on top of them if possible. By doing this, you can get a cleaner result, and you will be capable of storing them inside the box properly. Alternatively, you could just put the frosting on the top when you want to eat them.
Use the Right Container
Make sure only to use airtight containers for storing cookies. The ones that can not ensure an airtight inside will make the cookies turn hard. And that is something that you would definitely not want if you want to enjoy soft and chewy cookies. Also, do check whether the lid is properly in place or not before keeping the box in the fridge.
Thaw the Cookies after Taking Them Out of the Fridge
Properly thawed cookies will taste fresh, and you will feel like having the cookies right after baking them. And the easiest way to thaw the cookies is to keep the box on your kitchen counter after getting it out of the fridge. Depending on the room temperature and your cookies, it should only take one to two hours.
However, if you want to have the cookies ready as fast as possible, you can microwave them. But do remember that microwaving the cookies will make them lose their texture. And the cookie might turn soft all over. Nonetheless, to thaw the cookies with the microwave, just place them inside for sixty seconds.
Pick the Right Recipes
If you plan to store the cookies for a prolonged time, you should opt for simple recipes. The delicate cookies, such as the meringue-based treats, will not stand up well to storage. In comparison, chocolate chip cookies, shortbread cookies, icebox cookies, cutout cookies, and hearty bar cookies stand up quite well.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many cookies can I store inside cookie storage containers?
That will depend on the total capacity of the container and the size of your cookies. However, do not just cram as many cookies as you can inside the box. That will make the cookies break or lose their texture. Instead, layer the cookies and keep a little amount of spacing beside each.
Can I use any container to store cookies?
Not really! The containers that can not keep inside airtight are a no-go. Those will make the cookies lose their texture. For that reason, you should only use airtight containers to store cookies.
Can I clean the cookie container in a dishwasher?
It will depend on whether the container is dishwasher-safe or not. If you do not see any labels stating that it is dishwasher safe, you should not clean it inside the dishwasher.
Do cookie jars keep the cookie fresh?
If the jar can keep the inside airtight, then it should be capable of keeping the cookies fresh.
Are all cookie containers freezer-safe?
Not really! Some of the containers will start to crack or become brittle at low temperatures. You will not be capable of reusing them after keeping them inside the fridge for one time.
Without storing the cookies in the best containers for freezing cookies, you can not simply expect to get the right level of freshness. And the freshness level can change your entire cookie-eating experience. So, instead of keeping your baked goodness in regular containers, get one of the containers we reviewed right away!
About the Author
Tamara J. Sims
As a seasoned kitchen and food writer, Tamara has a remarkable ability to weave words together, transporting readers to the heart of the culinary world. Tamara’s articles are written with an engaging blend of insightful commentary, honesty, and real-world examples based on personal experiences. She has the ability to captivate seasoned food enthusiasts and novice cooks alike.
SeaRanchLodge.com is a participant in the Amazon Associate program and will earn from qualifying purchases.