No Popeyes meal is complete without one of the restaurant’s mouthwatering sauces. From their BBQ sauce to their Buffalo, Blackened Ranch, and even the Megan Thee Stallion limited edition sauce, all of them are quite delicious in their own way.
But hey, if you’ve never tasted them and would like to know what you’re putting into your mouth before you do so, we can help with that! We decided to try out some of the most ordered ones according to popular vote and found the best Popeyes sauce that you can order.
We tasted these sauces ourselves to provide an authentic review so you can just go ahead and enjoy the relishes we recommend. So, here are our opinions on the 7 sauces we found the tastiest.
Popeye BBQ Sauce
5 out of 5
Assorted Dipping Sauce Packets
5 out of 5
Creole Cocktail Sauce
4.5 out of 5
Blackened Ranch Packets
4 out of 5
Sweet Heat Sauce Packet
4.5 out of 5
7 Best Popeyes Sauce Review
With an assortment of sauces to choose from we picked only the 7 that people usually find the tastiest and tried them out ourselves to see what all the hype is about.
1. Popeye BBQ Sauce
This may come as a surprise to some, but Popeyes BBQ Sauce is the best barbecue sauce from Popeye. We know it’s a bold claim; but after testing and tasting a number of different sauces from our Popeyes sauces list, we can confidently say that Popeyes sauce is the best.
It’s got a great balance of sweetness and spice, and the heat is just right. But that’s not all about it.
The good thing about Popeyes' barbecue sauce is that it's incredibly versatile. It's great on chicken, of course, but it's also fantastic on wings, fries, and sandwiches.
Popeyes' classic barbecue sauce is spicy, tangy, smoky, and delicious — the quintessential wing sauce. However, their Memphis-style barbecue sauce is a little milder, but it’s still great for ribs, pulled pork, and even goes well with hamburgers.
When it comes to being the best Popeyes dipping sauce for dipping chicken, fries and pickle, the choice is obvious. The brand has perfected their sauce recipe and it all starts with their proprietary blend of 11 secret ingredients.
If you ask us, we would certainly recommend this bomb of a BBQ sauce, for all the reasons we have already stated. It tastes exquisite, with an explosion of sweet, spicy, and salty flavors and notes, so you should most certainly give it a shot to see whether you like it or not.
- Has a very smoky after-taste
- Contains a salty-sweet flavor
- Made from 11 different secret ingredients
- Goes very well with chicken tenders and wings
- Can be used for steaks and BBQ ribs.
2. Assorted Dipping Sauce
What if we told you, you can get an assortment of Popeyes sauces in packets? Wouldn’t that be even cooler? Good news is you absolutely can!
You can actually purchase a set of such sauces in dip packets instead of full sized individual sauce bottles or packs. This saves you a lot of money while offering variations as well.
Say you’re looking for the Popeyes sauce for nuggets. Judging by how convenient this set of relishes is, we definitely would consider it to be perfect for car trips. Because why not? You get a bunch of different sauces in convenient packages with various flavors to choose from, so what else can you even ask for?
But then, what relishes would you really get in this set? To summarize, you can get the Buttermilk Ranch, Wild Honey Mustard, Mardi Gras Mustard, and their BoldBQ. Since this is a set of different dips, we’ll talk about each of them individually.
The Buttermilk ranch has a bit of a salty yet milky taste, while the texture is quite thick and creamy. It tastes absolutely delicious with its mild sweetness, so it goes extremely well with chicken tenders and nuggets.
But if you prefer a more mustardy taste, you will like their wild honey mustard sauce. This one is more on the savory side, instead of just being slightly sweet. The combination makes it perfect for adding to burgers and sandwiches.
However, if you want to taste only the mustard, we recommend the Mardi Gras Mustard. You can get an even stronger mustardy flavor, which is a lot of people’s favorite. We personally prefer slight sweetness in dips, but hey, whatever floats your boat!
And lastly, if you’re someone who prefers a smoky barbeque flavor, you have to try out the BoldBQ sauce that you get from this assortment. This one has a hint of dark soya sauce for that umami hit, a bit of thick ketchup like texture, and a very smoky aftertaste. It goes really well with all of Popeyes’ food items, and of course, homemade fries and wings.
- Contains 4 different sauces; each 1.35 oz.
- Buttermilk Ranch, Wild Honey Mustard, Mardi Gras Mustard, and BoldBQ sauces included
- All available in little dipping packets
- The packets are portable so you can carry them around for on-the-go meals
- All the dips are very flavorful
3. Creole Cocktail Sauce
Next time you visit Popeyes, make sure to order the Creole Chicken Sandwich to try their signature creole sauce. We absolutely loved this delicious cocktail sauce, and turns out it’s a fan favorite as well! The sandwich itself features a mild spiced chicken breast served on a toasted French roll with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
But the star of the show is definitely the dip. The creole sauce is served on the side, and is an excellent dipping sauce for the fries in the sandwich, though we think it goes well with anything and everything. The sauce is also great on its own as a wing dip, and can be used to jazz up your favorite chicken fries.
Creole Sauce at Popeyes is also a great candidate to DIY at home. It’s actually incredibly simple to make, and only requires three main ingredients: ketchup, mayonnaise, and butter. Basically, everything you probably already have lying at home.
This fast food chain’s famous wing sauce is made up of 50% ketchup, with the remaining sauce made up of a blend of mayo, butter, and other secret seasonings. The blend creates a delicious wing sauce that’s been a game changer for fast food wings and is sure to impress even the biggest wing sauce connoisseur.
This allows you to customize the sauce to your liking and makes it easy to reduce or replace any of the ingredients to create a unique wing sauce. If you want it to have more heat, just add some cayenne pepper. Too spicy? Add oyster sauce!
On the other hand, you can also simply omit the butter and mayo to make a vegan wing sauce, or use reduced-fat versions to for a healthier option. How versatile is that?
- Made of ketchup, mayo, butter, and a few spices
- Contains some other secret ingredients that add some extra flavor notes
- Has a tangy and sweet taste to it
- Omitting the butter and mayo can make it a vegan option
- Comes in a packet of 1.35 oz.
4. Blackened Ranch Packets
Popeyes is known for its twist on the classic Louisiana flavor profile, with their Blackened Ranch sauce. The sauce is made with buttermilk, Cajun spices, and a blend of mayonnaise, Dijon, and ranch flavors. If you are like us and prefer hogging down on shrimp and jumbo prawns, this is the finest Popeyes sauce for shrimp items.
The blend is a great base to use for other sauces and dips as well, or even to mix into Popeyes' famous fried chicken. Popeyes Blackened Ranch sauce is a great option for when you want something a little bit different than the traditional ranch mixture.
We can guarantee that this sauce is great for when you want to add a Cajun kick to your meal. You can also use it to coat chicken, or just use it as a dip for fresh fries. The relish is a great option for when you want something a bit spicy and peppery.
Regular ranch is nice and all (we mean no hate!), but the Blackened Ranch just ups the flavor by a lot. Imagine an upgraded ranch that is spicier, smokier, and tastier! Yup, that is how this sauce is. Popeyes Blackened Ranch sauce is surely one of the good picks for fried chicken, in our opinion.
- Made of buttermilk, Cajun spices, and a blend of mayonnaise, Dijon, and ranch flavors
- Has a salty taste with a hot kick to it
- Features a spicier flavor than regular ranch
- Tastes a bit like the BBQ sauce with an addition of mayo
- Comes in a packet of 1 oz.
5. Sweet Heat Sauce Packets
Being a mild and sweet sauce with a little kick, the Sweat Heat sauce is great for dipping and adding to wings, nachos, pizza, salads, and more, especially for those who can’t stand heat.
The sauce is vegan and gluten-free, with no high fructose corn syrup, and is made with fresh jalapenos and habaneros for that slight kick (still, not too spicy at all, trust us). It tastes good when made fresh, but will keep for about a month when refrigerated. We recommend finishing it in at least 15 days for the best taste value.
As you may know, Popeyes is a popular restaurant chain that produces tons of different hot sauces. But it seems like the Popeyes Sweet Heat sauce is their most popular recipe among those who like things mild.
If you want that subtle heat with mild flavors party in your mouth, then you’ll definitely love this dip. It's really good and you'll probably keep licking the sauce packet well after finishing your meal at Popeyes. We certainly did! The taste is so captivating that most people fall in love with this delectable hot sauce.
If you want more spice for a change of taste, you can pair this vegan and gluten-free dip with any type of hot sauce, whether it's barbecue, jerk, hot or sweet chili sauce. It’s very easy to pair up with other condiments, so what’s there to not like about it?
Anyone who has a knack for spicy food will definitely fall in love with this amazing relish. It hits all the right notes and since it goes well with different items, we really think it deserves more recognition.
- Has a very spicy flavor
- Made with fresh jalapenos and habaneros
- Is vegan and gluten-free
- Does not contain any high fructose corn syrup
- Stays fresh even after being refrigerated for long periods
6. Bayou Buffalo Sauce Packets
What’s better than wings? Buffalo wings! The bold, spicy flavor of buffalo sauce is a classic pairing with chicken wings, but Popeyes’ unique flavor of buffalo sauce can be difficult to recreate at home.
The flavor of Bayou Buffalo sauce is a delicious twist on traditional buffalo sauce, with the addition of Texas Pete hot sauce for an extra kick.
You won’t find a better buffalo sauce than Bayou Buffalo. Popeyes' unique blend of spices and peppers is the perfect base for your favorite wings, but it can also be used as a dipping sauce for chicken fingers, fries, and more. After all, the Bayou Buffalo goes well with almost everything we tried it with.
The main part is that it’s ready in just minutes, so you can enjoy the bold flavor of the dip without having to wait for long.
The Bayou Buffalo sauce is really versatile. It goes great on wings, but it’s also great on burgers, pizza, nachos, and more. If you’re craving wings, but want to try something new, Bayou Buffalo is the way to go.
The most popular wings in America come from the Buffalo wing chain, Popeyes. And the Buffalo sauce dips are like the perfect add-on to them.
- Made from a unique blend of spices and peppers
- This one is quite spicy as well
- high on flavor and low on calories
- It’s got a sweet, tangy, and spicy flavor to it
- Contains Texas Pete hot sauce for an extra kick.
7. Megan Thee Stallion Hottie Sauce
If you love the artist, you’ll absolutely love this same-named dip too! Why? Because they’re both so spicy! The Megan Thee Stallion Hottie is the must-have ingredient for any serious hot sauce aficionado for its exquisite and unique taste (which we will describe in a bit).
The premium red habanero pepper is the sole source of the fruity and savory notes that sets Megan Thee Stallion Hottie apart from other hot sauces on the market.
Try adding a few drops of this dip to your favorite dish for a fiery, flavorful upgrade. Or, for maximum heat, try adding a few drops to your regular ketchup or marinade before serving.
The first thing you notice about Popeyes’ Megan Thee Stallion Hottie sauce is its, well, name (funky, we know right?) and bright red color. This rich hue is the result of the exclusive blend of peppers used to craft the sauce, which delivers a complex, fruity flavor profile.
The next thing you notice is the burn. Megan Thee Stallion Hottie packs a fiery punch, thanks to its blend of habaneros and other peppers.
Popeyes dipping sauces have long been the go-to for delicious chicken, but the brand has expanded to include an impressive assortment of menu items. From original chicken to catfish to shrimp, Popeyes has something for everyone.
Among the menu’s standout offerings is the spicy Megan Thee Stallion Hottie sauce. This limited-edition sauce is a blend of red habanero and ghost peppers that promises to add a fiery kick to just about anything. Jam to your next favorite Megan Thee Stallion album with a side of this hot dip and chicken wings!
- Spicy with a fiery punch
- It has a bright red color to it
- Made of habaneros, ghost peppers, and other peppers
- The peppers deliver a complex, fruity flavor profile
- A few drops of this sauce offers intense levels of heat
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Which is the best Popeyes sauce for shrimps?
Their Blackened Ranch is usually a fan favorite when coupled with their in-house popcorn shrimps. We also think the slightly smoky aftertaste from the sauce pairs up well with fresh seafood.
2. Are Popeyes sauces good for barbeques?
Absolutely. Most of their sauces are ideal for casual bites, such as with fries and popcorn shrimps. However, drizzle a whole bunch of their special sauces over barbequed meat for a tangy and smoky experience.
3. What sauces does Popeyes have?
Popeyes has a range of permanent in-house and limited-edition sauces, but your location determines which ones you will find at your nearest outlet. Their signature sauces, however, are the Bayou Buffalo, Mardi Gras Mustard, Blackened Ranch, Sweet Heat, and Buttermilk Ranch.
4. Why are Popeyes BBQ sauces so sweet?
The reason behind Popeyes BBQ sauces being sweet on the tastebuds is because of the added molasses in the dip. Instead of sugar, the molasses provide a slightly burnt sweetness to the sauce, making it perfect to go with barbequed meat.
5. Which is the best Popeyes dipping sauces?
In our opinion, the Bayou Buffalo Sauce Packets is a winner. You get tanginess, sweetness and the heat in one dip! How can anything else beat that?
Although each Popeyes sauce holds a special place in our hearts (and stomachs!), we still can’t get over the taste of the Bayou Buffalo Sauce Packets. It’s the perfect condiment to go with almost all kinds of items!
However, if you want something more peppery or smoky, the BBQ sauce and the Blackened Ranch are two great options.
But if you’re yet to choose your own favorite, we hope our 7 Best Popeyes Sauce Review was able to give a head start on what to experiment with.
SeaRanchLodge.com is a participant in the Amazon Associate program and will earn from qualifying purchases.